Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[Robins Retweet]

Just wanted to know how everyone rated our players overall last season out of ten

Here's mine.....

1. Stuart COBURN, 8
2. Shaun DENSMORE, 7
3. Matt DOUGHTY, 7
4. Carl RODGERS , 5
5. Gianluca HAVERN, 8
6. Scott LEATHER, 6
 7. James LAWRIE, 7
8. Simon RICHMAN, 8
9. Duncan WATMORE, 10
10. Damian REEVES, 9
11. Nicky CLEE. 7
12. Danny HALL, 6
 14. Pat LACEY, 7
15. Jake MOULT, 6
16. Ryan BROOKE, 5

[ForeverAlty]

Just wanted to know how everyone rated our players overall last season out of ten

Here's mine.....

1. Stuart COBURN, 8
2. Shaun DENSMORE, 7
3. Matt DOUGHTY, 7
4. Carl RODGERS , 6
5. Gianluca HAVERN, 9
6. Scott LEATHER, 6
 7. James LAWRIE, 7
8. Simon RICHMAN, 9
9. Duncan WATMORE, 10
10. Damian REEVES, 9
11. Nicky CLEE. 8
12. Danny HALL, 6
 14. Pat LACEY, 7
15. Jake MOULT, 8
16. Ryan BROOKE, 4

[ForeverAlty]

Putting Moult and Brooke on the same rating is definitely incorrect... Moult netted 9 from CM since January

[Robins Retweet]

Putting Moult and Brooke on the same rating is definitely incorrect... Moult netted 9 from CM since January

moults on 6 for me and brooke 5, maybe if he would of started more i would have gone higher so i suppose he should be an 8 at the end of next season.

[DAB @ ALTY]

I think that Scott Leather should at least have been rewarded an 8 in the list.

[bigedd]

I know it sound soft.but i would  give them.all 10. For a great effort. well played all of the team.
Bring on the new season.and get behind all the lads.Come on you mighty ROBINS.

[GolfRoader]

Just wanted to know how everyone rated our players overall last season out of ten

Here's mine.....

1. Stuart COBURN, 8
2. Shaun DENSMORE, 7
3. Matt DOUGHTY, 7
4. Carl RODGERS , 5
5. Gianluca HAVERN, 8
6. Scott LEATHER, 6
 7. James LAWRIE, 7
8. Simon RICHMAN, 8
9. Duncan WATMORE, 10
10. Damian REEVES, 9
11. Nicky CLEE. 7
12. Danny HALL, 6
 14. Pat LACEY, 7
15. Jake MOULT, 6
16. Ryan BROOKE, 5

Very harsh on Rodgers IMO. I think he gave us something different that we needed to get a result in some games.

[Jimmy]

Stu 7
Dens 7 
Buzz 7
Luca 8
Leather 7
Hall 5
Bosh 8
Moult 7
Clee 8
Lawrie 6
Rodgers 6
Richman 8
Lacey 5
Brooke 5
Reeves 9
Dunc 9.5

[bighairedmike]

Stu 7
Dens 7 
Buzz 7
Luca 8
Leather 7
Hall 5
Bosh 8
Moult 7
Clee 8
Lawrie 6
Rodgers 6
Richman 8
Lacey 5
Brooke 5
Reeves 9
Dunc 9.5

Very fair that Jim. I'd possibly bump Leather and Richman up one, but no qualms about the rest.

[Ballers]

Putting Moult and Brooke on the same rating is definitely incorrect... Moult netted 9 from CM since January

moults on 6 for me and brooke 5, maybe if he would of started more i would have gone higher so i suppose he should be an 8 at the end of next season.

Why have you edited this just to be controversial?  You just had it right what you said about Moult being a touch higher than you originally gave but now you've given him less than Lacey?

Is that baby ignoring you now or something?

[Robins Retweet]

Putting Moult and Brooke on the same rating is definitely incorrect... Moult netted 9 from CM since January

moults on 6 for me and brooke 5, maybe if he would of started more i would have gone higher so i suppose he should be an 8 at the end of next season.

Why have you edited this just to be controversial?   You just had it right what you said about Moult being a touch higher than you originally gave but now you've given him less than Lacey?

Is that baby ignoring you now or something?

ballers, i dont see what my child has to do with my opinions on alty players???

Having adverse opinions shouldnt mean im trying to stir controversy.

[scousr alty]

Are you mad Leather 5? How many positions did he fill very well,had one bad game against a very good old pro,very very harsh!

[scousr alty]

Sorry 6 but still harsh very harsh,future of Alty top player.

[Robins Retweet]

Sorry 6 but still harsh very harsh,future of Alty top player.

for me he has good potential but i think 6 is fair comparing his performances with some of the other players in important matches.

[Jenga]

Stu 3
Dens 2 
Buzz 4
Luca 1
Leather 1
Hall 10
Bosh 5
Moult 4
Clee - who?
Lawrie 6
Rodgers 6
Richman 1
Lacey 2
Brooke 10
Reeves 2
Dunc - never heard of him.