I'll try and clear a few things up.
The only flare that has been common knowledge to those who frequent Moss Lane was indeed the one that was used during the Brackley game in the 2012/2013 season. I know that because I attended the game with those responsible, and I'd say on that day there were about 20-30 who knew about it. After the mixed response on the forum after that game, there has not been any such item brought in by a regular Altrincham fan and I can say that with assurance.
There was a red smokebomb let off away at Stockport towards the end of last season and as far as I am aware that was brought in and used by a group of lads who do not regularly attend Altrincham matches. They were stood right away from the core bulk of Altrincham fans and that is always a strong indication.
The green (and I still don't understand why it was green) smokebomb that was let off during the home leg of the play-off semi-final against Hednesford was also done so by fans who do not regularly attend Altrincham matches.
Again, tonight, there was one red smokebomb and it was set off by fans who I don't believe to be Altrincham regulars. It was brought in by a group of teenage lads. I noticed they were planning it well before the second half started and I told them that if they were going to do it then they'd better make sure it was done "properly." By that I mean do not throw it on the pitch. Unfortunately they did that.
There were not two smokebombs tonight, only the one. Also I'm pretty sure that the Macclesfield fan who came bounding over was the one who threw it back onto the pitch but I cannot confirm that.