Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[robininstockport]

Neil tolson

Worse shout ever

Honest question - Why?


I'm not being obtuse I am genuinely interested in your reasoning

His record at Hyde, Bowerman was his call.

We need someone with a fresh outlook and mimimal history of the squad  

[Timperley The Best]

Surprised Ken Mckenna hasnt bee mentioned , also local ex league manager Paul Dickov although he  has no conference experience.

[robininstockport]

Ken McKenna!

Ffs give up

[finnquark]

[Jimmy]

Why are people obsessed by the past,up to the board to work hard in finding a manager who hasn't failed hear before

[Timperley The Best]

Ken McKenna!

Ffs give up

not for me but thought someone would have mentioned him

[chesteralty]

Colin Little. No explanation necessary.

Well there is. I'm sure there is a bit of difference between conference football and City's U8s.

So Colin has no experience of conference football?

As a manager, no. He also has limited coaching experience, and pretty much none at men's level. I find it very odd that you even mention him.

The idea of an ex player managing a non-league club is clearly ridiculous, sorry to even mention it, I mean, when does that ever happen?
Personally I would rather have someone who loves the club and has experience here than an outsider.



[/quote]

[wayno]

Where is chris senior these days ?

[GB Alty]

All them 3 would be bad choices

I will repeat the question - Why?

When Lee was appointed a number of people decried the appointment as he had "No Altrincham FC pedigree"  Two of the candidates listed above have significant Altrincham pedigree (I later found out that what was actually meant was experience at the Club incidentally)

Again I am not being obtuse I genuinely am interested in folks thought processes on this

nice guy, and I know your his friend

But is his management record really good enough for this level? I am open minded about it

[distancetraveller]

Why are people obsessed by the past,up to the board to work hard in finding a manager who hasn't failed hear before

Good post Jimmy
Lets get somebody who hasnt got a  connection to the club.

[Jenga]

Where is chris senior these days ?

HAHAHA.

[TheCultOfIanTunnacliffe]

Neil tolson

Worse shout ever

Honest question - Why?

I'm not being obtuse I am genuinely interested in your reasoning

As Lee Sinnott's assistant, surely he also bears some responsibility for the major predicament in which we now find ourselves?

Sorry but wouldn't be my choice under any circumstances.

To turn the question on its head, I'd be interested to see you make the case for his appointment.

[Mick]

Dino Maamria or Jim Harvey oh........keeping someone else up 

[Toff Apple]

Morrell, currently at tamworth

[eightiesrobin]

All them 3 would be bad choices

Absolutley. Neil Young didn't have a job for two years after Chester were relegated. His stint at County was a bit of a disaster too. Tolson, like Cult says, is at least partly implicated in the current dire straits, while Graham Heathcoe's last 3 managerial gigs (Alty, Stafford & Trafford) have ended with relegation. For me, something different is needed. I've long thought that Jim Gannon was the type of manager who'd do well here, but that ship has sailed.