Ah, with Lutel James you're now talking about an ex BUry player who had done well in the conference with Accrington. Whata complete and utter let dow he was.
So to change tack slightly who is the most disappointing ex ALty striker? For me, I expected more from Gary Powell when we signed him but he was startlingly ineffective. Howver I don't think we paid much for him so as far players we paid for, well, Martin Hanchard was dead highly rated but I was suprised at him when he got here. I think Colin WIlliams wasn't quite what we had hoped either although by then he was past his prime I guess.
On the plus side Ken McKenna was a big signing, cost money but was someone we knew was a class player. He surpassed himself while at Alty though (and indeed since he has left). Sometimes your heroes turn out to be not what you hoped, getting to know them sometimes can shatter a lot of dreams, not Kenny Mac. True Alty legend.